Throughout his work, Twelfth Night, Shakespeare stresses that stereotypes regarding gender hold no validity, ultimately deeming them inaccurate. Yet in today's society, such stereotypes still exist. Even in this day and age, women are viewed as fragile, while men are considered more strong and powerful. I think it is important that we consider Shakespeare's messages about gender so that we can come closer to eliminating these stereotypes. Though considerable progress has been made over the years, I believe that our society still has a long way to go in regards to gender expectations.
In the second act of Twelfth Night, Orsino and Viola--disguised as Cesario-- discuss the love between men and women. Orsino claims that "there is no woman's sides/Can bide the beating of so strong a passion/As love doth give my heart; no woman's heart/So big, to hold so much; they lack retention" (II.iv.103-106). However, Viola soon retorts that "In faith, they are as true of heart as we" (II.iv.117). She later adds that "We men may say more, swear more, but indeed/Our shows are more than will; for still we prove/Much in our vows but little in our love" (II.iv.128-130). By suggesting that men do not follow through with their commitments in regards to love, Viola challenges Orsino's idea that men are full of passion that women are unable to match. Here, Viola displays her disagreements with such stereotypes that Orsino mentions. This goes on to contribute to Shakespeare's ideas that these stereotypes are invalid as Viola outwardly disagrees with someone who holds power over her.
In the "Shakespeare Gender Swap!" clip we watched today, those who conducted the experiment changed the name of of certain Shakespeare characters so that readers believed they were the opposite sex. All of the information and details about the character remained the same, with the only difference being the gender. Readers described the female character as "immoral, manipulative, and weak," while the exact same character as a man was described as "brave, smart, and lustful." I think that this says a lot about how society views women in comparison to men. Even with the exact same actions, the female version of the character is considered flawed while the male version is superior. This clip highlighted that people today still have different gender expectations.
Though stereotypes are still prevalent today in many ways, there certainly has been a great amount of progress. I recently saw a video about a campaign by "Always", challenging the use of the phrase "Like a Girl" in an insulting context. In the video, a few young women in their late teens are asked to, for instance, give there best impression of what it means to "run like a girl". All of these older girls ran clumsily with their arms waving around, clearly fulfilling the interpretation that many of us have of this phrase. However, much younger girls, around ages 6-10, where asked to do the same thing. When asked to "run like a girl", these girls ran powerfully, pumping their arms and taking long strides. This commercial seeks to eliminate the degrading connotation that the phrase "like a girl" has. When someone says that another person does something like a girl, this generally means that they do it poorly or that they are weak, yet this association between girls and weakness is inaccurate. In truth, this phrase should have absolutely no negative connotation whatsoever, as doing something "like a girl" should not be any less powerful.
It is still incredibly important to consider Shakespeare's ideas about gender in our society today, because while progress is being made, stereotypes still exist, with both women and men being generalized and viewed a certain way.
I'm going to have to look up that video and add it to my collection. Well-developed ideas here, Siobhan!
ReplyDelete