Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Fate and Free Will Pre-Reading Thoughts

1. Exercising our free will plays an important role in determining our path. Having the ability to express our opinions freely while ignoring the judgement of others is imperative in our development; through our free expression, we develop our personal identity. How we identify ourselves is what dictates the major life choices we make and the path that we find ourselves on. Roger Williams, a historical figure, is a clear example of one who strongly exercises their free will. Williams was banished from the Massachusetts Bay Colony for rejecting Puritanism. Following his banishment, he went on to create a new colony in Rhode Island, where he stressed religious libertarianism. This colony was incredibly successful, and if Williams had not exercised his free will, such religious tolerance may have never been born.
2. I think that to a degree, we are all "actors", especially in an age where social media is such a phenomenon. Honestly, social media is all about perception, and when it comes to perception, we all have an ideal self. We all hope to appear bigger or greater than what we are; Instagram, for example, is a way that people show what is going on in their life. However, someone is only going to post the moments they want people to see. They are only posting the highlights of their life, so that we all get an incorrect representation of exactly who someone might be. While it obviously makes sense that one would only want to post their highlights, this creates a false sense of identity because we live in a time where people are identified through their Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook accounts, rather than who they actually are as a person.
3. I don't think that revenge is justifiable. I've always been taught to "keep my side of the street clean", and I think that is an important idea to uphold. I personally would never want to seek revenge on someone simply because that is what I have been taught. Considering hypothetical situations can make the answer to this question more difficult, though. If you consider a familial situation where, for example, a child in the family has been threatened, many would believe that the parents of this child have a right to revenge. Yet I think that in this age, it makes far more sense to rely on the justice system rather than seeking revenge. In terms of suicide, I think it is very difficult to say whether it is completely justifiable or unjustifiable. However, I come to find that it is entirely up to the person considering it. It's so easy for someone to say that when someone else commits suicide they are being selfish and rash, but at the same time, it is impossible for this person to truly understand what the other person is going through. Some people commit suicide because living has become unbearable; after years and years of dealing with a mental illness, spending every day suffering, they find that it is the only way to truly alleviate their pain. I don't think it's right to say that suicide is unjustified because many people have problems beyond our understanding that are unable to be solved. While suicide should absolutely be a last resort, sometimes it is the only answer for someone that has lived a life full of suffering.
4. In my opinion, madness can be defined in different ways. It could be defined by irregular or chaotic behaviors, which can often times be attributed to a mental disorder. It can have many different contexts, but society, specifically, tends to hold mental illness in a very negative light. To this day, there is still unfortunately a stigma around such illnesses. Madness can also be defined as the questioning of authority. By this, I mean that someone who questions the ideas of those in a position of power may be labeled as "mad." Even still, a label of insanity can be used as an instrument of power. Going back to my example from above, Roger Williams was most likely labeled insane by many, yet it was this questioning that allowed him to become more powerful and begin his own society.

Sunday, November 30, 2014

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner

     In The Rime of the Ancient Mariner by Samuel Taylor Coleridge, an old sailor recounts his experiences at sea to an unsuspecting wedding-guest. He explains how he wrongly killed an Albatross, detailing the many problems that ensued at the hands of nature. Coleridge emphasizes the importance of respecting nature, as it ultimately holds power over man, through the use of literary devices such as personification and religious allusions. 
     Instances in which Coleridge utilizes personification strengthen his idea the nature must be respected, so as to avoid its damage and destruction. For example, as the mariner tells his story to the wedding-guest, he recalls how sheets of ice seemed to overtake the ocean: “it cracked and growled, and roared and howled, like noises in a swound!” (Coleridge 2). By adding that the ice did things such as growl and roar, Coleridge develops a sense of power among this seemingly harmless and stationary force of nature. Personifying the ice, which takes place in the beginning of the poem as the mariner first begins to recount his experiences, creates a sense of equality between man and nature. It even seems to present the ice as having authority over man. Additionally, wind is personified later on in the mariner’s story, as he says “it mangled strangely with my fears” (Coleridge 7). Here, a force of nature is once again given a sense of power and authority, as in this instance, the wind seems to terrorize the mariner, mangling “strangely with [his] fears”.  Personification ultimately reveals the capabilities of nature to wreak havoc and cause destruction, which further presents the idea that it deserves respect from man.
     Coleridge emphasizes this point through the use of religious allusions, as well. These allusions are used to purify nature and question how one could ever possibly harm it, specifically regarding the killing of the Albatross by the mariner. For example, as the Albatross is first seen flying overhead the sailors, the mariner says “as if it had been a Christian soul, we hailed it in God’s name” (Coleridge 2). Comparing the Albatross to a “Christian soul” highlights it’s purity, which therefore criminalizes the mariner further as it remains unbeknownst to all why he would kill such an innocent creature. A religious allusion to God is also employed by Coleridge at the end of the poem as the mariner leaves the wedding-guest, in which he says “He prayeth best, who loveth best all things both great and small; for the dear God who loveth us, He made and loveth all” (Coleridge 9). The mariner communicates this upon exiting to emphasize the importance of treating things in nature with respect, as God created all things to be equal. The mariner does not want the wedding-guest to make the same mistakes that he made, therefore repeating “he prayeth best, who loveth best” to strengthen his points, as he believes God will reward those who treat the nature and its inhabitants with love and respect.
     Through the use of literary devices such as personification and religious allusions, Coleridge portrays his idea that nature must be respected as it is incredibly powerful and can control man.

Monday, November 24, 2014

Unit Essential Questions

1. I think that humans tend to react to isolation very differently. In some cases, they may react adversely, desiring social contact with others. Continual isolation may eventually cause one to recede into it and learn to accept it. Instead of changing their current situation, some people may simply embrace it. Over time, this could lead to negative effects in which the isolated person is cut off from society and human contact. I think that humans need interactions with others in order to be stable, so being completely cut off from society in isolation would prove to be extremely damaging. Yet at the same time, many people desire isolation, for a limited time, at least. For instance, in the novel Into the Wild by John Krakauer, the main character Chris McCandless goes into isolation in the woods in order to free himself from the constraints of society. In my own life, I actually enjoy being alone and undisturbed. However, after too much time elapses, I once again get either lost in my own thoughts, or simply bored, and want to spend time with other people. How humans react to isolation depends entirely on that person.
2. Individuals need human interaction to feel human. These interactions and relationships with others often lead one to feel validated and loved. In Psychology class, however, we recently learned about a case study involving a young girl named Genie, who was kept alone in a room for thirteen years of her life. The only time she was exposed to other people was when her parents left food for her or yelled at her, so Genie essentially had little to no human interaction for this first part of her life. It caused tremendous damage to Genie, which, although an extreme example, displays the incredibly negative effects on a person who lacks human interaction, and therefore, does not feel human.
3. When we don't take responsibility for our actions, we can damage our relationships with others. If someone makes a rash decision that also concerns someone else, it can be equally damaging to both people, whether they are the person who made the bad decision or simply the person who is indirectly involved. Then, by not owning up to our actions, this can lead to even further conflict. It's important that we follow through with what we say through our actions and take responsibility, so as to avoid dragging others into situations that originally they were not a part of.
4. Lack of compassion or understanding leads to prejudice and stereotyping because the person who lacks compassion fails to see things from others' perspectives, and therefore makes generalizations or assumptions based on their preconceived ideas. For instance, as we discussed quite a bit while reading Twelfth Night, there are still many problems regarding gender inequalities in today's society. Women still tend to be viewed as weaker and less able than men, which is a stereotype that has been present for centuries. While there clearly has been a great amount of progress made, it is still an issue that cannot go unnoticed.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Twelfth Night Act 4 Response

     While 4.3 of Twelfth Night may at first appear insignificant due to its short length, it is very important as it builds suspense and ultimately contributes to the theme of misunderstanding that is so prevalent throughout the play. In this scene, Sebastian ponders how lucky he is to have come into contact with someone like Olivia, recognizing that neither of them are insane. Olivia professes her love for Cesario, who is actually Sebastian, by asking for marriage, saying "Plight me the full assurance of your faith" (IV.iii. 27). Such a statement produces suspense for the reader, as it would be assumed that Olivia will soon discover who both Sebastian and Viola truly are. Sebastian happily agrees, though he is still confused as to how he found himself in such a situation. He does not want to reveal this confusion to Olivia, however, as he believes that "this accident and flood of fortune so far exceed all instance" (IV.iii. 11-12). Though Sebastian recognizes that there is much more to the situation that he does not know about, he is so pleased with the possibility of a relationship with Olivia  and is satisfied with this "flood of fortune" that he ignores any concern he may have about the situation. This scene also contains dramatic irony; Olivia and Sebastian happily plan to marry each other, but Sebastian's true identity is unbeknownst to Olivia while the audience is aware that drama will soon unfold and true identities will be revealed. Because it strengthens themes present throughout the play, such as misunderstanding, and also builds suspense, Act 4 Scene 3 of Twelfth Night is a necessary part of the play.

Thursday, November 13, 2014

Are Shakespeare's messages about gender still necessary for society to consider today?

     Throughout his work, Twelfth Night, Shakespeare stresses that stereotypes regarding gender hold no validity, ultimately deeming them inaccurate. Yet in today's society, such stereotypes still exist. Even in this day and age, women are viewed as fragile, while men are considered more strong and powerful. I think it is important that we consider Shakespeare's messages about gender so that we can come closer to eliminating these stereotypes. Though considerable progress has been made over the years, I believe that our society still has a long way to go in regards to gender expectations.
     In the second act of Twelfth Night, Orsino and Viola--disguised as Cesario-- discuss the love between men and women. Orsino claims that "there is no woman's sides/Can bide the beating of so strong a passion/As love doth give my heart; no woman's heart/So big, to hold so much; they lack retention" (II.iv.103-106). However, Viola soon retorts that "In faith, they are as true of heart as we" (II.iv.117). She later adds that "We men may say more, swear more, but indeed/Our shows are more than will; for still we prove/Much in our vows but little in our love" (II.iv.128-130). By suggesting that men do not follow through with their commitments in regards to love, Viola challenges Orsino's idea that men are full of passion that women are unable to match. Here, Viola displays her disagreements with such stereotypes that Orsino mentions. This goes on to contribute to Shakespeare's ideas that these stereotypes are invalid as Viola outwardly disagrees with someone who holds power over her.
     In the "Shakespeare Gender Swap!" clip we watched today, those who conducted the experiment changed the name of of certain Shakespeare characters so that readers believed they were the opposite sex. All of the information and details about the character remained the same, with the only difference being the gender. Readers described the female character as "immoral, manipulative, and weak," while the exact same character as a man was described as "brave, smart, and lustful." I think that this says a lot about how society views women in comparison to men. Even with the exact same actions, the female version of the character is considered flawed while the male version is superior. This clip highlighted that people today still have different gender expectations.
     Though stereotypes are still prevalent today in many ways, there certainly has been a great amount of progress. I recently saw a video about a campaign by "Always", challenging the use of the phrase "Like a Girl" in an insulting context. In the video, a few young women in their late teens are asked to, for instance, give there best impression of what it means to "run like a girl". All of these older girls ran clumsily with their arms waving around, clearly fulfilling the interpretation that many of us have of this phrase. However, much younger girls, around ages 6-10, where asked to do the same thing. When asked to "run like a girl", these girls ran powerfully, pumping their arms and taking long strides. This commercial seeks to eliminate the degrading connotation that the phrase "like a girl" has. When someone says that another person does something like a girl, this generally means that they do it poorly or that they are weak, yet this association between girls and weakness is inaccurate. In truth, this phrase should have absolutely no negative connotation whatsoever, as doing something "like a girl" should not be any less powerful.
     It is still incredibly important to consider Shakespeare's ideas about gender in our society today, because while progress is being made, stereotypes still exist, with both women and men being generalized and viewed a certain way.


Tuesday, November 4, 2014

SPOTTTS Analysis: "Diving into the Wreck"

S: Self-exploration and discovery
P: The diver organizes their equipment and prepares to dive alone.
As they are about to begin their descent, they reflect on the ladder and its' innocence.
They descend down the ladder and adapt to their new environment, unsure of where the ocean will begin.
At first, the diver feels out of control as they experience the ocean, but soon realizes that they have the power to successfully complete this dive.
The diver acknowledges how easy it is to forget their purpose in this new sea environment.
Recounting their original purpose, the diver explains their goal to explore this underwater wreck and any treasures that may be hidden.
The diver is filled with a new sense of motivation, as they desire to experience the wreck, rather than simply read about it.
The diver details the beauty and mysteriousness of the wreck by creating the mermaid and merman, both of which are figments of their imagination and make them feel powerful.
Exploring the wreck, the diver discovers those who lost their lives, their belongings rotting in the wreck.
The diver explains human curiosity and their desire to revisit the wreck, as they are drawn to it even though it may not concern them directly.
O: The occasion of the poem is a diver exploring a shipwreck in the ocean, possibly seeking self fulfillment or personal growth.
T: The title "Diving into the Wreck" sets up the reader for what the poem will be about, giving them an indication of the events that will take place. The wreck may serve as a symbol for personal struggles or difficulties.
T: The tone of this poem is captivating, contemplative, and determined.
T: The speaker suggests that while both self-reflecting and having new experiences can be frightening, such as this descent into the ocean, they are necessary in order to achieve growth or gain new understandings as individuals in order to overcome struggles.
S: The speaker is a diver who utilizes stream of consciousness to reveal her thoughts and ideas.



Tuesday, October 28, 2014

The Awakening Criticism Response

     I agree with the argument presented in Yaeger’s critical essay on The Awakening, as Edna never truly liberates herself from man. Throughout the novel, she strives to free herself from the constraints of her husband, Léonce. While she is successful at liberating herself from Léonce, man continues to have power over her for the duration of the novel. 
     In Yaeger’s essay, she asserts that after she is “freed from the repressive talk of her husband, Edna chooses another mode of oppression, a speech-world that offers space for flirtation that Edna finds liberating” (Yaeger 287). Edna has an incorrect definition of liberation; she does not emancipate herself but instead thrusts herself even deeper into the role of a stereotypical damsel in distress, “as if romance were the only form of elation a heroine might feel” (Yaeger 286). She relies on Robert, who, unbeknownst to her, exerts force over her and hinders her progress towards her empowerment.
     Her relationship with Robert in the second part of the novel completely discredits the idea of being free, as she looks to him as a means to make her happy and feel whole. Yet by having Edna rely on Robert, Chopin contradicts the character’s original desires to question the conventions of society and stand alone. Instead, she becomes increasingly dependent on Robert, though she views this dependency as liberation.
     Even the referral to Alcée’s hand as “magnetic” (Chopin 125) supports the idea that Edna is rendered powerless by man, engulfed by passion and her desire for physical attention. When Robert leaves her one night, she continually asks “you will wait for me?” (Chopin 147), which highlights her increasing dependency on him as she is afraid of being alone. Though Edna succeeds in liberating herself from her husband, the novel is contradictory in the sense that this “liberation” is accompanied by a growing sense of dependency.