I agree with the argument presented in Yaeger’s critical essay on The Awakening, as Edna never truly liberates herself from man. Throughout the novel, she strives to free herself from the constraints of her husband, Léonce. While she is successful at liberating herself from Léonce, man continues to have power over her for the duration of the novel.
In Yaeger’s essay, she asserts that after she is “freed from the repressive talk of her husband, Edna chooses another mode of oppression, a speech-world that offers space for flirtation that Edna finds liberating” (Yaeger 287). Edna has an incorrect definition of liberation; she does not emancipate herself but instead thrusts herself even deeper into the role of a stereotypical damsel in distress, “as if romance were the only form of elation a heroine might feel” (Yaeger 286). She relies on Robert, who, unbeknownst to her, exerts force over her and hinders her progress towards her empowerment.
Her relationship with Robert in the second part of the novel completely discredits the idea of being free, as she looks to him as a means to make her happy and feel whole. Yet by having Edna rely on Robert, Chopin contradicts the character’s original desires to question the conventions of society and stand alone. Instead, she becomes increasingly dependent on Robert, though she views this dependency as liberation.
Even the referral to Alcée’s hand as “magnetic” (Chopin 125) supports the idea that Edna is rendered powerless by man, engulfed by passion and her desire for physical attention. When Robert leaves her one night, she continually asks “you will wait for me?” (Chopin 147), which highlights her increasing dependency on him as she is afraid of being alone. Though Edna succeeds in liberating herself from her husband, the novel is contradictory in the sense that this “liberation” is accompanied by a growing sense of dependency.